These are my Islander year in review on the team players to date. These were done by myself, as well as John Panarese, my colleague on the eyesonisles.com site. Hope you enjoy them. Please crituque anything that you like. Thanks and enjoy!
#43 – Martin Biron
29GP 26GS 9-14-5 3.25GAA, .896 SV Pct, 1SHO, 1A, 2PM
Probably on of the nicest hockey players that I have ever encountered, Marty is the ultimate team player. He knew EXACTLY what he was getting himself into when he came here. However, he would do whatever was necessary for the team, and not complain about it.
At one point of the season, he got zero support from the offensive side of the puck. He would give up 2 goals on 40 shots, but get zero from his mates. At a point where he was not getting any playing time, he took a stint in Bridgeport to keep his game shape going. Then in a stretch at the latter part of the season, he was on fire for the big club.
He knew he was the 3rd wheel on the team chart when Ricky returned briefly to the lineup, but the ‘class’ guy that he is – he kept chin up and did what was needed.
I know that he will not be back next season, but if a team had 20 guys like Marty, it would be a great locker room. Not that the Islanders have a bad one, in fact the team is a great unit together; but he is an absolute treat. Whatever team that will get his services next season will have a great player on and off the ice.
As far as a grade is concerned, I have to give a C. For total playing it would have to be lower, due to the bad start, and the bad luck. However, the intangibles will take some of the grade and bring it up.
Next up – #44 Freddy Meyer.
#42 – Dylan Reese
Here is a guy who went from playing in one organization to being traded to the Islanders and then being called up days after that. Basically, with all of the injuries to the back line at the time, the Islanders desperately needed someone to plug the proverbial hole. Thus, in stepped Dylan Reese.
Reese played in 19 games, and picked up a pair of goals and a pair of assists. He also was a +4. Frankly, he simply did a great job being literally put right into the fire. He adjusted to the NHL rather quickly, and I can recall Billy Jaffe making the observation a number of times in regard to how well Reese was playing his position and making the “smart plays”. I don’t think we could have asked for much more from the guy under the circumstances.
It’s hard to grade a guy who played under 20 games, but I’d still have to give him a B. He really stepped into a difficult situation and made the best of it. The unfortunate reality, however, is it’s highly unlikely that he will find himself making the top 6 for the big club next season. I, of course, could be entirely wrong about this, but it seems that the Islanders may be looking at a few future prospects who might be ready to make the jump to the NHL. Thus, Reese’s potential role on the Isles would be quite limited at best.
#38 – Jack Hillen
3G, 18A, 21Pts, -5, 44PM, 1PPG
Amazing that he only missed just a few games from the shattering of his jaw, thanks to Alex Ovechkin’s slapper.
To me – this young man from Colorado College by way of Minnesota – made the most strides of any player on this team. Not just from the offensive or defensive standpoints, but the impression standpoint. To me – the beginning of the season, Jack looked a bit uncomfortable with the puck. This skill was told to be one of his best. As the season progressed, and the comfortability level got more and more improved, you can see that he was not just a young second year NHL player, but he looked like a solid veteran. He almost looked a little Bourque-like.
I think another full year under the belt for Hillen will show the experts that he is ready to be known as a strong 20-25 minute a game player that will handle himself with authority, as well as provide a little offense when it is needed. Can he be a top 4 defensemen for this team for years to come? I really think that he can do that.
As far as a grade, I will give him a B-. A grade that I believe will continue to improve. I think he will need to add about 5-10 extra pounds, and work on his speed. This should make him be a player that will potentially make an impact for this team for the forseeable future.
#32 – Brendan Witt
As you may noticed, I did Jack Hillen and not Brendan Witt. Only because I do not feel that he is a part of the future of this team, that I did not do the review. As far as a grade, I would have to put him as a D. For his ‘warrior mentality’ that kept it away from an F. I would give him an “A” for Super Hero powers, as he battled the GMC Yukon outside the Wachovia Center in Philly earlier in the season. Brendan had a good career, but he is too slow for this NHL, and I just don’t think he is long for the league.
Next to review – #42 – Dylan Reese.
#30 – Dwayne Roloson
Another of the off season signings by Garth Snow that proved to be valuable well beyond expectations. Just how many games Roloson single-handedly won for the Isles over his 49 starts is hard to figure. No one really could have expected the efforts we got and the value of #30. I can recall one game earlier in the season against the Maple Leafs up north in which Dwayne faced 60 shots and was the Only reason why the Islanders ended up winning the game.
What more could you have asked for from a veteran goaltender on a rebuilding team? A 3.00 GAA, and a 23-18-7 record. I couldn’t even begin to estimate how many times in a game Roloson shut the door with an amazing save to hold a lead or keep the Isles in a game. You simply couldn’t have asked for more from the 40 year old net minder. Like Matt Moulson, Dwayne Roloson was truly one of the big and pleasant surprises for the New York Islanders this season.
So, I’d have to give him an A minus. No, he wasn’t perfect, but he surely gave the Islanders quality goaltending throughout the season. Undoubtedly, he will be a part of the goaltending picture next season, as there are still unanswered questions about Ricky’s future.
#28 – Tim Jackman
54GP 4G 5A 9Pts -4 98PM
He a was providing a nice job on the 4th line, killing penalties, being an overall nusiance to the opposition, until New Years Eve when he broke his orbital bone in a fight in Ottawa.
That derailed the former Columbus draft pick for over two months. There was a sense of a slight loss of toughness with this team (that Trevor Gillies picked up when he was recalled). However, Tim possesses the sense of what a proper 4th liner should be. I think he can offer more of an offensive position should it be required. He is not a loss on the ice without it, as he has a sense of a defensive responsibility to the team.
He is a RFA this season, and he is one that I really think that should be kept with the team next season. Are you hoping for 15 goals from him? No. But 10 is not out of possibility with him. He can surprise you with that, and be the straw that can stir up the team. He has a good personality and seems to be a good guy in the room.
I will give him a C+ (that may be a little low), because I think he can be better for this team with his roles. I think he needs to step up to the next level, and I think he can do it. With the salary he can make, it would also be a real bonus for the team.
Next up – #30 – Dwayne Roloson.
#26 – Matt Moulson
82GP – 30G, 18A, -1, 16PM, 8PPG, 5GWG
The find of the year in the entire league in my opinion…. That has NO BIAS written into it at all.
A 26 year old that was stuck in the minors – not getting the chance, was given a shot by the Islanders in camp.
Did he impress? What do you think!
He was told he made the team, but the coaching staff told him to play every game like it was his last. Even after the great start he had, he still played that way. As a matter of fact, he did that for all 82 games, leading the Isles in goals with 30. His comfortability with his fellow Missisauga native John Taveras, led to a comfort zone for both the rookie and the veteran AHL’er.
We have not seen a player stick his body in front of the net – to get rebounds and get to pucks, since Mark Parrish. A dirty goal to him is a goal indeed. He did not look like a deer in headlights, in fact, the deer was charging the nets.
To see the flowing locks with the big smile after a goal, it almost looked Bossyesque (well – change the hair color and you had a chance). With nothing expected, the returns are immeasurable.
He is a RFA this year, and I have NO DOUBT, that the Isles will take care of him. There should be no reason to want to go anywhere else. The Isles took the chance that NO one would. Besides, he is playing with JT, and that can’t be all that bad…
I give him an “A”. There will be so much more expected of him this season. He will have expectations, and people to bicker if he doesn’t comply. Will he get the same amount of numbers? I really think he will. It will not be as easy; teams will be looking for him. However, with a young corps another year experienced, there has to be heads turning.
Next up – #28 Tim Jackman
#24 – Radek Martinek
Martinek played only 16 games this season, totaling 2 goals and an assist for 3 points and a -1 rating. Unfortunately, a knee injury cut his season short in November, which has seemed to be a recurring theme for him ever since he entered the NHL. I don’t think he has played a full season or over 60 games in a season since he joined the Isles.
Martinek is a very solid defenseman who has been quite impressive when he has been able to get his game going. In both the defensive and offensive aspects of his game, he has been an asset, but, again, his problem has been his inability to stay healthy. I can only give him a C for this season because of having not even played 20 percent of the total games for the season.
It is going to be interesting to see what his future holds on Long Island. Undoubtedly, Radek can be a force on the back line and, if he can remain healthy, can challenge for a spot on the roster. However, with the young talent coming along and the potential for free agent acquisitions, I don’t know if he has a definite place among the final 7 who will make the team next season.
#21 – Kyle Okposo
19G, 33A, 52Pts, -22, 34PIM.
Twice consecutively just missing on the 20 goal plateau, but career record in points with 52.
He is progressing just as I would expect of him when he was drafted from the USHL. He has flashes of brilliance; to me – a Jerome Iginla type of player. Nasty when he needs to be – great hands, great vision on the ice, and the type of person to make a nothing into a major something.
He had a couple of dry spells where he looked like a little lamb missing his mother, but that is to be expected from most 23 year olds. The good part about him, is that those spells seem to be short lived, and almost nearly forgotten.
Wearing the “A” – he could be the next Captain of this team, a position that he could probably hold for years and years. Seeing him in the locker room, he is definitely a quiet presence. He is quite affable, and gets his point across simply with an ease about him. That is what you expect from a potential captain.
Can he improve? Absolutely. He needs to find more opportunities, and get down in the slot, and muscle around to get to loose pucks. He does have a good shot from the point, but in my opinion, he is not the quarterback on the PP. He should be the fullback, driving, and creating holes (on the goalie – that is).
Any team would want to build a team around a talent, and a man like Kyle. The sky is definitely the limit with #21. I give hima B+, only because of his stretch that he did not produce. Yes- it is a ‘youth’ thing, and it probably is a good thing that this happened.
Next up – #24 – Radek Martinek…
#20 – Sean Bergenheim
To me, Sean is another of the “enigma” players the Isles have seemed to have in their lineup. A guy with a great deal of potential talent, he often did not show much of it and, at times, took the over aggressive penalty. However, when he got hot, we could see his value, and I have found myself wondering a number of times just what this guy can be if he put his game together for a full season.
In 67 games, Bergenheim totaled 10 goals, 13 assists, 23 Points and was a +1 with 45 PIM. He had his share of injuries, but no one can deny that he is a guy who plays with heart an intensity when he is on his game. The question, though, is whether or not he can establish his impressive game over the course of an entire season. It seems as if he has turned it on at the tail end of the last two. I’d have to give him a C+ as a rating, as I just think that Bergenheim has far more to offer than we have seen.
On a side note, I also want to congratulate the Hawks and Flyers for their accomplishments in the playoffs. It is going to be a great Stanley Cup final round. The young Hawks against the amazing Flyers. My personal prediction is … Chicago in 6.
#16 – Jon Sim
Stats: 77GP 13G 9A 22PTS 44PM
An enigma if there ever was one. Simmer is the kind of a player that his role would be more relished on a stronger team than the Islanders. He is a pest, a person that will tick off the front line, plays much bigger than he actually is – and can get involved in the offense as the situation dictates.
At the end of 08-09 – he was languishing in Bridgeport – wondering if he would be an NHL’er again. As the season ended, he was playing good minutes and getting the team fired up. You always see him slapping gloves and sticks of his teammates, and trying to get the guys pumped up. He is never going to be a top6 forward, but a 3rd line agitator is a good choice.
I will give him a B- for this year, only because there were some moments in this season, where he was as lost as Oceanic 815 (No – I never watched a second of LOST, but I know the flight number). However, in the right situation – he may help a team tremendously. Will he be signed next season? I have my doubts. He is a warrior and a good team guy, but Garth needs to take this team to the next level; and too many ‘good guys’ will just not do it. He needs ‘better than good guys’ to mold with the Tavares’ and Moulsons of this team, as well as the kids that are coming.
Next player will be #20 – Sean Bergenheim
#15 – Jeff Tambellini
I guess the word, enigma, would describe this young man. Let me first say that this is a kid I have pulled for since the Islanders got him, especially with his father’s connection to the early Isles. There was a brief time in which the patience of Scott Gordon and the organization appeared to be paying off, as Jeff showed some confidence and talent for a stretch. However, for whatever the reason, Jeff simply could not put it together for us, and soon became a daily healthy scratch. One cannot say that this kid didn’t get his share of chances, and he was inserted into the lineup a number of times.
Tambellini was a -8 in 36 total games, having tallied 7 goals and 7 assists. Unfortunately, I think he picked up most of his goals in two multiple goal games, including a hat trick. Beyond that, however, the guy just couldn’t seem to find his place in the NHL. He scored a lot at Bridgeport, but this never translated into the kind of player we needed him to be.
Sadly, at this stage, the “Tambellini experiment” seems to be over. Perhaps, a change of scenery and a new organization would do the young man well. I’d honestly have to give him a D-, as I wouldn’t say his earlier glimpses of talent made him an utter failure. Still, I do not believe you will be seeing Jeff in an Islanders’ sweater next season.
#14 – Trevor Gillies
First of all – congrats to the Flyers… What an unbelievable upset! Boston just laid down and died! And dont use the too many men as an excuse. If it was called 2 or 3 time in the playoffs, that is one thing, but 33 times????? No – you just did not get it done, and it is another black eye for Boston sports. This may hurt worse than Buckner.
Trevor Gillies – 14 games – 1 assist, 75 PIM -2
Yes – the Isles had a very good record when he played, but sorry fans, he is NOT the reason for it. I like his passion, his ’stepping up’ and defending his teammates. He knows when to make the issue be big, and when to back off.
If Trevor was 21, I would really like his future. However, he is a journeyman, with these 14 games on his NHL resume. Could I see him back here next year?
Sure.
However, he would seriously need to step the rest of his game, and not be a 5 minute a game player. Can he do that at 31? It is a big question, to see — I would definitely bring him to camp and see what kind of desire he has.
As far as a grade is concerned, I will give him a solid C+. I am a little tough on the grade, because he needs to step up the rest of the game.
Next up – Jeff Tambellini… This should be a doozy!
#13 – Rob Schremp
I must admit that I wasn’t initially impressed with Rob Schremp. He was released by the Edmonton Oilers, and though his skills were said to be fantastic, we didn’t really see that at first. However, it didn’t take long for Schremp to start to demonstrate his abilities, particularly in shoot out situations in which we saw a very impressive bunch of “tools” in his box.
Before a knee injury cut his season short, Rob Schremp played a total of 44 games. He had 7 goals and 18 assists, and was a -4. Every game, he seemed to get better and better, and I can remember thinking to myself that, like with Matt Moulson, we had really gotten ourselves a steal in Rob Schremp. As his confidence grew, he became more impressive, and it was clear that Scott Gordon and the staff were equally impressed. It is difficult to give a guy a true grade when an injury cut short what might have been a really extraordinary season, but I’d have to say he was a B building himself to become better than that. We shall see what training camp brings for Rob Schremp next season and if he continues to improve and shine out on the ice to possibly make a bid at a top 6 forward spot or certainly a third line guy.
#10 – Richard Park
I was supposed to put this in numerical order – but I forgot Park. A former Nystrom award winner and all. Great ciizen and leader for this young squad.
Stats from this season.
81 GP, 9G 22A 28PM, 4GW, -9
That last number at one point was around -20, but it improved as the team showed possible playoff signs in March.
I can NEVER say anything bad about Parkie. He gives effort, and always seems to be a part of the action when he is out there. He plays shifts as if it may be the last. Not to say he is banging heads and working at 120% of his energy level. He is just smart in his actions. He is a great PK man, who has helped in many of a shorthanded goal for this team.
For the Dollar value, Park is a great asset. However, it will be a big decision on management on whether he remains next season. I think a quiet leader, and great citizen are values that Garth and ownership take real seriously. Therefore, I hope that he remains next year, as an important cog of this team.
As far as a grade is concerned, I will give him a C+. I would like to see the +- number to be a little higher, but getting 30 points a year is about where I expect. If it was just on intangibles, I would put him at an A- level.
Next is Rob Schremp.
Hopefully my Numbers are correct, right John???
#12 – Josh Bailey
Our first round draft pick in 2008 started to come on later in the 2008-2009 season. He had somewhat of a slow run out of the gate this year, but we soon started to see the skill the Islanders were hoping Josh would begin to demonstrate. Josh spent some time moved over to the left wing, which seemed to help his scoring quite a bit, and the confidence and his general presence on the ice seemed to build. Instead of “flying by” the net, “Bails” often did not shy from going to the goal and creating scoring chances for himself and his teammates. In fact, though I might be incorrect here, I believe he had 2 short-handed goals and a couple of game winners for the Isles.
In 73 games, Josh totaled 16 goals and 19 assists for 35 points with a +5 defensive rating. . He missed a little time to an injury right before the olympic break and then missed the last couple of games of the season, but to me, the improvements we saw in Bailie were very promising. I’d have to give him a B+ rating overall, as I think he definitely proved that he has top 6 potential for the future offense of the New York Islanders. The question will be whether or not Scott Gordon and the staff will decide to shift him back to center, as they did later in the season, or utilize him on the wing where he seemed to show his best offensive output.
#8 – Bruno Gervais
Stats from the Islanders Site:
71GP (career high) 3G, 14A, 17P, -17, 31PIM, 1PPG, 1GWG, 83Shots, 3.6%
The Islanders version of Jekyl and Hyde. There are some games, where the Longueuil, QC, native was outstanding and was making strides to be a much better NHL defenseman. Then – Mr. Hyde showed up, and made his presence felt, leaving many a fan looking for a quick kill.
The problem is – when a player usually has one of these blips, it is usually a short term thing, and then their game returns. For Bruno, I think his last name should have been Tonioli (as in Dancing with the Stars host).
As far as a representative of the team, there are few better. He is involved, seems to love the Island, and represents the team so respectfully and with a great character. If that could relate to points on the scoresheet, please, get us some more of that. But we all know that it is not the case.
It seems that the issue with the number 8 player on the scorecard has always been consistency. Sometimes when you see him coming up the defensive zone, you want to push his stick and say to get that puck upto the rushing forward. Also – there is no surprise among the thousands in attendance, as to his intentions.
That is the main topic of his game that needs work, is the consistency factor, because there is instances where you shake your head and say how much improved, Bruno can be. Then there are times where you shake your head and say how far back he has gone in his development. If he wants to move up to the next grouping of an NHL defenseman, he needs to take Mr. Hyde and shove him to the curb.
I give him a C- this year. He really needs to move up the echelon, and working on his consistent play should be his primary focus.
Next review – #12 – Josh Bailey
#7 – Trent Hunter
Let me start off by saying that I am a big Trent Hunter fan and as one who cannot play the game of hockey, I am very uncomfortable offering criticism of those who do play the game of hockey on a professional level. With that said, from the perspective of a fan, Trent Hunter did not provide us with the best of seasons from his ability of being an offensive weapon for us.
In 61 games, Trent tallied 11 goals and 17 assists for 28 points with a +3 rating. He missed 21 games in total because of injuries, which has been an issue for him over the last few years. When he returned from his first injury, he had something like a 9 or 10 game point scoring streak, and it looked like he was going to, perhaps, approach his 25 goal area he once gave us. However, this did not prove to be the case at all in the end.
Without a doubt, Trent’s defensive zone coverage is a strong point and his ability to play on the PP and PK, as well as his size and physical presence, makes him an important player for the Isles. Even so, we need more than 11 goals from him. We need him to use his size, go to the net and be a factor every game. There were just some games where he didn’t seem to be completely present, despite his value on the PK or his defensive game. Overall, all things considered, I would, unfortunately, have to give him a D rating for this season as we need a lot more from #7 on the ice in the future.
#4 – Mark Flood
He was an emergency call up for what became a patchwork defense at times and played 6 games with the Isles. According to the stats, he had 1 assist and was a -4 rating over the 6 games he played.
It’s hard to grade a guy who was thrown into the fire and had his development process rushed quite a bit. Also, because of this, his ice time was limited for the most part. It’s hard to say what Mark Flood will eventually bring in the future for us, but he certainly did well enough for the big club. Thus, I would give him a B rating, though I add the disclaimer that his 6 total games and limited ice time makes it difficult to give him a full appraisal.
#2 – Mark Streit
For these reviews that John and I will do – we will do it in numeric order. So since we do not have a #1, I guess #2 will do.
Mark Streit
Here is his stats.
Games 82, Goals 11, Assists 38, Points 49, +- 0, 48 PIM, 9 PPG, 2 GWG, 187 Shots 5.9% efficiency
Yes, the numbers are a little behind last years stellar numbers, but in this season, he did not have to take the defensive scoring load all to himself. He was able to play fully in all three zones with a little more comfortability.
He was fifth in the league with minutes played per game with over 25. And with his quiet demeanor, he led by example. I think players like Andy MacDonald, and Jack Hillen will definitely get some skills and advice from the “A”.
I really think Montreal would like to re-think their position by not re-signing him last year. They just did not rely on his defensive capabilities and showed the NHL what kind of player he really is.
Mark is a solid foundation for a young defensive corps that have a great base to build on. With three years to go on his contract, he is showing that the money given to him was defnintely worth it.
I give him a B+ this year.
I am sure that John will add his thoughts on this and grade him too.
Next review – Mark Flood #4.
These are the reviews to date. Check on this site, as well as my other blog site, which is www.eyesonisles.com, part of the FAN SIDED NETWORK, for more Islander information.
Posted under 2009-10 Review
This post was written by Gary Harding on June 24, 2010
Last night – Garth Snow was at the Booster Club meeting. He is one funny dude!




With new coach Scott Gordon in place and goalie Rick DiPietro coming back, the New York Islanders seem to be ready to go into 2008-09.
